Pia's On Broadway

Nestled in the heart of Orangeville, ON, Pia’s On Broadway offers a delightful culinary experience that masterfully blends the warmth of a beloved bakery with the vibrant flavors of a contemporary restaurant. This charming spot at 177 Broadway has become a cornerstone for locals seeking fresh, thoughtfully crafted meals in a cozy, inviting atmosphere.

Specializing in elevated sandwiches and fresh-made salads, Pia’s on Broadway boasts a menu that caters to both classic tastes and adventurous palates. Their Arugula Salad bursts with peppery greens perfectly balanced by crisp textures, while fan favorites like the Steak Sandwich Medium Rare and the Catfish Burger deliver a tender, juicy satisfaction that will leave you craving more. The Chicken Sandwich with a Side of Greens is a standout option for those wanting a light yet flavorful meal. Not to be missed are their house-made fries—both the traditional French fries and the irresistibly sweet sweet potato fries, each boasting a crispy, golden exterior that perfectly complements their rich, succulent sandwiches.

The bakery roots of Pia’s shine through in every detail, especially with their freshly baked breads that frame each sandwich with a perfect, soft bite that speaks to craft and care. Whether you’re indulging in a savory Cobb Sandwich or a comforting bowl of their Potato Pear Soup, the quality of ingredients and meticulous preparation is evident. They also thoughtfully cater to younger diners with simple yet satisfying options like the Grilled Cheese Sandwich and the classic B.L.T, ensuring a welcoming experience for families.

The ambiance at Pia’s is truly something to savor in its own right. With a rustic, cozy vibe that locals describe as both charming and elegant, it’s the kind of place where you can feel completely at ease—whether you’re enjoying a quiet lunch or celebrating a special occasion. As one loyal guest, Luvy Jawanda, puts it, the atmosphere coupled with exceptional service makes it "the most charming and delightful restaurant I have ever visited."

Customer experiences repeatedly highlight not just the delicious food but the genuine warmth and attentiveness of the staff. Marc De Groote’s glowing praise for his 60th wedding anniversary party speaks volumes about the attentive service and memorable dining experience Pia’s consistently delivers. The vibrant local buzz often makes reservations or a quick phone call for takeout a smart move, ensuring you never miss out on one of the most talked-about dining experiences in town.

Whether you’re stopping by for a quick coffee and dessert break during a downtown shopping trip, indulging in a leisurely lunch, or celebrating a milestone with friends and family, Pia’s On Broadway offers a rare blend of fresh flavors, heartfelt hospitality, and a warm neighborhood vibe that leaves a lasting impression. It’s more than just a meal—it’s an experience crafted with care and passion in every bite.